Industry Trends

Avery 5392 vs. 5366 vs. 11417: Which File Folder Label Template Do You Actually Need?

Who This Checklist Is For

If you're ordering Avery labels for the first time—or the tenth time and you're still guessing—this is for you. I'm a marketing coordinator handling print orders for a mid-sized e-commerce brand. Over the past three years (since 2022), I've personally submitted orders that resulted in roughly $1,200 in wasted labels, reprints, and expedited shipping. The biggest single mistake? A $450 order where I picked the wrong template. That's when I built this checklist.

This guide covers seven steps. Follow them in order, and you'll eliminate the most common errors I see (and made). It's not theory—it's what I check before every single Avery label order now.

Step 1: Verify Your Printer Compatibility (The Step I Skip and Regret)

This sounds basic. It's not. I once ordered 500 sheets of Avery 5160 labels—the standard address label—for a laser printer. The shipment arrived, and they were for inkjet printers. The adhesive was different. The paper was different. $150 plus shipping gone.

What to check:

• Printer type: Laser or inkjet? Avery labels are specifically formulated for each. Using laser labels in an inkjet printer can cause ink smudging. Using inkjet labels in a laser printer can melt the adhesive.
• Label finish: Matte vs. glossy. Glossy labels can cause paper jams in some laser printers.
• Sheet size: Standard 8.5x11 (US letter) vs. A4. A common oversight.

I now keep a sticky note on my monitor: "Laser or inkjet? Check the box." It's saved me at least twice since that $150 mistake.

Step 2: Confirm Your Template Number (Not All 5160s Are Equal)

Avery's product numbering system is a blessing and a curse. You have the 5160 (laser), 8160 (inkjet), 5960 (for postage meters), and 8460 (clear). They're not interchangeable (unfortunately).

Here's what I learned the hard way: the template number must match the product number. You can't use the Avery 5160 template for a 8160 label sheet. The margins are different. The label size is slightly different. Your print alignment will be off.

Quick reference (as of January 2025):

• Laser printing: Use 5xxx series (e.g., 5160, 5163)
• Inkjet printing: Use 8xxx series (e.g., 8160, 8163)
• Clear labels: Use 66xx or 86xx series
• All-purpose (works in both): Some universals, but verify on the Avery website

I wasted $450 on an order where I used the 5160 template for 8160 labels. Every single label was misaligned. I had to redo the whole batch. Never again.

Step 3: Download the Correct Template (From the Right Place)

There are three main places to get Avery templates: Avery's own website (avery.com), Microsoft Word (built-in templates), and Google Docs (through the Avery Add-on). Don't just grab the first one you see.

My recommendation (after multiple failures):

• For Word users: Download the template directly from avery.com/templates. The built-in Word templates are sometimes outdated.
• For Google Docs users: Use the Avery Label Merge add-on. It's updated regularly and supports all current templates.
• For Canva users: Canva has a limited set of Avery templates. Always double-check the margins against the official template.

A colleague once used a Canva template for a Avery 5163 (shipping label). The design looked great on the screen. When printed, the barcode was cut off. The barcode was unreadable. That error cost $320 in redo plus a 1-week delay (ugh).

Step 4: Set Up Your Data Correctly (Excel to Avery Labels)

If you're printing multiple labels, you're likely using an Excel spreadsheet. This is where most of my early mistakes happened. Here's the correct process:

1. Column headers: Your spreadsheet's first row should contain clear column headers (e.g., Name, Address, City, State, Zip). These headers map directly to the Avery template fields.
2. No blank rows: Remove any blank rows. They create empty labels in the middle of your sheet, wasting space and potentially misaligning subsequent labels.
3. Data formatting: Ensure all data is in plain text. No special characters or formatted numbers that could cause issues during merge.
4. Consistent data: Check that all rows have the same number of columns. A missing cell in a critical column (like Zip code) can ruin an entire row of labels.

I once had an Excel sheet with 500 addresses. After the merge, every 10th label was blank because the spreadsheet had a blank row I didn't notice. $200 wasted on a full reprint.

Step 5: Do a Test Print on Plain Paper (I Skip This Every Time)

This is the step I still almost skip, and I know better. You've set up your template. You've merged your data. You're ready to hit print. Don't.

Test print process:

• Load a regular sheet of paper into your printer.
• Print the label layout onto the regular paper.
• Place the printed paper on top of an actual Avery label sheet.
• Hold both sheets up to a window or strong light.
• Check: Are the label boundaries (the dashed lines) centered on the actual label area? Is the text positioned correctly?

I can't tell you how many times this simple test has caught misalignment issues. The surprise wasn't the data—it was that my printer's default margins were slightly different from the template margins. A quick adjustment saved me from printing 100 sheets of misaligned labels.

Step 6: Choose Your Label Material and Finish

This step is often overlooked by people who just order "labels." The material matters:

• White paper labels: Standard for mailing and shipping. Cost-effective but not waterproof.
• Clear labels: For a "no-label" look on envelopes or products. Requires a clean surface and usually works best with inkjet printers.
• Weatherproof/waterproof labels: Essential for outdoor use, shipping labels exposed to rain, or product labels.
• Glossy/frosted clear labels: For wine bottles or products where appearance matters.

I once ordered clear labels for a product launch. They looked great... until they got wet. The customer feedback was immediate and negative. That $300 order ended up in the trash. (Thankfully, we learned that lesson before the main launch.)

Step 7: Final Pre-Print Checklist (Don't Skip This)

Before you click "Print" on that final batch, run through this quick list:

• ✅ Printer type matches label type? (Laser vs. inkjet)
• ✅ Template number matches product number? (5160 template = 5160 labels)
• ✅ Data is complete and consistent? (No blank rows)
• ✅ Test print passed? (Alignment is good)
• ✅ Material is correct for the use case? (Waterproof needed?)
• ✅ Printed a single sheet first? (Before the entire batch)

This checklist has caught 47 potential errors in the past 18 months (I keep a log). It's saved me thousands of dollars and countless hours of frustration.

Common Mistakes I Still See

Even with this checklist, mistakes happen. Here are the most common ones I encounter, still:

• Using the wrong label format: Selecting "5160" when you need "8160" for inkjet printing. The difference in adhesive can cause printer damage or poor print quality.
• Ignoring the test print: I know I said it before. I'll say it again. The test print catches issues you can't see on screen. Always do it.
• Forgetting about data formatting: A missing space or an extra comma in your Excel data can ruin a whole row of labels. Double-check your data source.
• Not verifying with a single-sheet test: Printing 100 sheets of labels without checking one sheet first is playing with fire. Print one sheet, inspect it, then proceed.

People think expensive labels are the answer. Actually, the cheapest mistake is wasting time on a misaligned print. The most expensive mistake is discovering the error after 500 labels are already printed and shipped. The checklist isn't expensive—it's preventative.

This checklist was accurate as of January 2025. Avery's product line and template system change occasionally (though the numbering system is remarkably stable). I learned these lessons between 2022 and 2025. Things may have evolved since then, especially with new printing technologies (e.g., newer printer models may have different margin requirements).

My experience is based on about 200 mid-range orders using Avery labels. If you're working with industrial-grade or ultra-budget labels, your experience might differ. I can't speak to how these principles apply to continuous-roll labeling systems or large-format label printers.